Carl Wilson is not a fan of Celine Dion's music. Getting tired of all the oppression-based critique of narrative art. Have I really just spent the last 3 days convincing my friends, loved ones and neighborhood shop keepers how misunderstood and really amazing Celine Dion is?.Thanks to this fantastic book, I have. At times even a beautiful book, with none of the cynicism that the premise (a non-Celine Dion fan writing about Celine Dion) or series (known for in-depth looks at respected albums, with varying levels of quality and pretension) would suggest. What makes something a guilty pleasure instead of music you are proud to admit you enjoy? We asked the... Non-fans regard Céline Dion as ersatz and plastic, yet to those who love her, no one could be more real, with her impoverished childhood, her (creepy) manager-husband's struggle with cancer, her knack for howling out raw emotion. (A Dance With Dragons) Authors who I've read in depth The first and last novels that made me cry Stranieri, by Tristan Gans Chicklit novels Life is too short to waste time on boring books Against Interpretation, by Susan Sontag God's Harvard, by Hannah Rosin The Pillow Book, by Sei Shonagon If you die and leave me with your brilliant unfinished manuscripts, I will burn them Comedic novels Adrian Tomine's Optic Nerve comics Fun Home, by Allison Bechdel The Grapes of Wrath, by John Steinbeck The joy of short novels Crime novels with interesting structures Woman as financial vampire Old School, by Tobias Wolff And The Band Played On, by Randy Shilts The Sportswriter, by Richard Ford Some pretty awesome plotless novels The poverty and evanescence of literary acclaim in SF Why I am deeply suspicious of Malcolm Gladwell The Hunger Games, by Suzanne Collins The first science fiction novel Do you folks enjoy reading poetry? He remains adamant about what he perceives as the characteristics of Celine’s music–sentimentality, a lack of innovation, and a lack of cultural (and self) awareness. He’s one of my all-time favorites. Even the 33 1/3 titles that would seem plum targets for the irony game — ABBA Gold, for one — have passed through the karaoke vortex and been certified cool. 3. I think this is the better book. Tedious tripe. Prescriptive based on descriptive is good, I think. “as a former bullied kid, I always figured it started from rejection. AND I think I finally understood all those Kant readings from 1 page of this book. You made me want to read both Wilson and more of you. The Game of Thrones television show is superior to the books. Anatomy of a literary pageturner Bleak House, by Charles Dickens A Journal of the Plague Year, by Daniel Defoe Vanity Fair, by William Makeapeace Thackeray “If the world could write by itself, it would write like Tolstoy.” Wired Magazine Farthing, by Jo Walton Red Plenty, by Francis Spufford Wide Sargasso Sea, by Jean Rhys Burmese Days, by George Orwell Horatio Hornblower, by C.S. Granted, all of those make for relatively acceptable listening, but what about Céline Dion? In the end, the real value of this book is in the tools that it gives to the reader: Wilson provides a way of thinking–a mode of internal dialogue–that allows the reader to interrogate his own tastes. Yes, definitely. Or, at least, we don’t treat it that way. Read 2 reviews from the world's largest community for readers… I’m excited for you- I went on a big Lewis kick a while back and read all of his stuff (well, his more accessible stuff- a lot of his more academic writing is on or in ancient greek). I love that Wilson never falls down the rabbit-hole of total subjectivity. Carl Wilson’s Let’s Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste. Sam. "LETS TALK ABOUT LOVE" BY CARL WILSON READING SUMMARIES Chapters 1-4 Summary (One Paragraph): The book, “Lets Talk About Love” by Carl Wilson, analysis the music and life of Celine Dion. Share. Carl Wilson manages to drop Fanon and Kant all over the place and not be remotely pretentious! It would be no solution to say we have to love everything, the equivalent of loving nothing. Shop for Celine Dion Let's Talk About Love: (33 1/3) from WHSmith. By (author) Carl Wilson. Along with being a tremendously important piece of criticism, Let's Talk About Love is an agile, moving, and generous exploration of the music that accompanies us, welcome or not, on the travels we all need to make on our own. AKA, this book is freaking awesome. Being not only Canadian, but a Quebec-born French Canadian myself, I can certainly match, if not exceed, Carl Wilson's distaste for Céline Dion. “Let's Talk About Love” is a studious, A-plus paper on the topic of “taste,” but it's also very dry, very quote-heavy, and very resistant (to use one of the author's, Carl Wilson's, own key words) to its own innate charms -- those charms being its personal touches: the book sparks to life in moments (like when Wilson flashes back to his ex-wife's performance of Buddy Holly's “Oh Boy” to express her feelings for her then … Continuum International Publishing Group. At once among the most widely beloved and most reviled and lampooned pop stars of the past few decades, Céline Dion's critics call her mawkish and overblown … The Power and the Glory, by Graham Greene, Does anyone actually enjoy cliffhangers? In fact, during the angstier moments of my youth, I was certainly prone to listening to Celine’s “My Heart Will Go On”. For his 2007 critically acclaimed 33 1/3 series title, Let's Talk About Love, Carl Wilson went on a quest to find his inner Céline Dion fan and explore At once among the most widely beloved and most reviled and lampooned pop stars of the past few decades, Céline Dion's critics call her mawkish and overblown while millions of fans around the world adore her “huge pipes” and even bigger feelings. Thousands of products are available to collect from store or if your order's over £20 we'll deliver for free. $24.99; $24.99; Publisher Description. II. I’d never even heard of “An Experiment in Criticism”, but I have been meaning to check out some of C.S. Thoughts engendered by my return to computer gaming after an absence of two and a half years We should all stop being so self-deprecating The Television / Refrigerator Axiom. by Carl Wilson. Older albums covered — Music From Big Pink, Forever Changes, Court and Spark, Dusty in Memphis — have for years been hailed by the new kids on the indie block as favorites. That’s what Carl Wilson sets out to discover in his look at Dion’s album Let’s Talk About Love. Even I'm not that crazy! For me, reading this book providing a road-map for journeying into the heart of my own motivations. My bad taste was untainted by any sort of hipsterish swerve (a prelapsarian self that I have, perhaps unfortunately, lost forever). Let’s Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste. That's part of her appeal as an object of love or hatred — with most critics and comm. In essence, Wilson asks whether his distaste for her music is really a way to distinguish himself from her fan base. There's nothing cool about Céline Dion, and nothing clever. Let's Talk About Love: A Journey To The End Of Taste, by Carl Wilson The Feminine Mystique(part one and part two) The Pursuit of Love, by Nancy Mitford. We’ve also been liberated by “poptimism,” whose major text, Carl Wilson’s Let’s Talk About Love, has just been reissued. Just a moment while we sign you in to your Goodreads account. If a colleague at work asks what I’m listening to on my iPod, how can I possibly respond by telling them I’m listening to Ice Cube or Jethro Tull or Nine Inch Nails without them getting certain ideas about the kind of person I am? I remember being at sound-system dances and hearing everyone from Bob Marley Kenny Rogers (yes, Kenny Rogers) to Sade to Yellowman to Beenie Man being blasted at top volume while the crowd danced and drank up a storm. Personally, I often struggle to produce criticism that is descriptive rather than prescriptive. We know that taste is not entirely subjective. Suffice it to say, Wilson gets something out of the whole endeavor. Why do they then go further and say “My kind of stuff [be it novels, movies or pop music] is actually, Have you ever laughed at someone who claimed to actually enjoy Celine Dion's music? For his 2007 critically acclaimed 33 1/3 series title, Let's Talk About Love, Carl Wilson went on a quest to find his inner Céline Dion fan and explore how we define ourselves by what we call good and bad, what we love and what we hate. Very few emotional effects are more vilified than the sentimental, and very few emotional effects are so detrimental to a work’s odds of being considered a high-quality, durable work of art. Carl Wilson tackles Céline Dion‘s album Let’s Talk About Love.. His approach is intriguing, based mostly upon the theories of sociologist Pierre Bourdieu (particularly as set forth in his Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste).). Start by marking “Let's Talk About Love: A Journey to the End of Taste” as Want to Read: Error rating book. What do you do when the writing isn't easy? Great….these are aaaaaall going on my list. Wilson’s aim is to examine taste. And, in an earlier section (while watching Celine’s Vegas show): “And this…is why Celine winds up mocked, because her efforts at class and taste always go wrong. English. It’s more academic and direct than ‘Let’s Talk About Love,’ and also has the advantage of having been written before ironic appreciation came along and thoroughly muddled how we think, or ought to think, about ‘bad’ art. Oh cool! I always feel as though I’ve been given a brief moment in which to explain myself, to justify my own choices in a kind of secret language which ends up revealing far more about my personality than I might wish other people to know. Lewis’ nonfiction work. “And the places she turns up in Jamaica are all the more curious. $10.95. We laud people with ‘good taste’ and revile those with ‘bad taste’. Her Purse Smelled Like Juicy Fruit book. Older albums covered — Music From Big Pink, Forever Changes, Court and Spark, Dusty in Memphis — have for years been hailed by the new kids on the indie block as favorites. The kind of contempt that’s mobilized by “cool” taste is inimical to that sympathy, to an aesthetics that might support a good public life.”. The only thing that it’s still per-se uncool to like (except in a hip, self-aware way) is the mainstream: that thin slice of very popular work (primarily marketed towards middle-aged people) that exists in sort of a null territory–stuff like Two And A Half Men or a Tom Clancy novel. Why do people like this kind of stuff and not that kind of stuff? Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. I read ‘Let’s Talk About Love’ on your recommendation, and really enjoyed it. Plus, I listed to. His writing style and perspective about taste and perception. I've just freed myself from the tyranny of duotrope On becoming a worse writer Where I get my stories from Why I am going to stop giving out writing advice (2012) Why I am loathe to give writing advice (2011) Revising the novel The worst-case scenario for my writing career, There should be a National Coming-Out Day for people whose favorite novel is _Atlas Shrugged_, My decade in love, friendship, and publishingI don't think reading books is likely to make a person smarter, happier, or more economically productive, Five classics that ought to capture you from page one, Let's Talk About Love: A Journey To The End Of Taste, by Carl Wilson The Feminine Mystique(part one and part two) The Pursuit of Love, by Nancy Mitford, Getting tired of all the oppression-based critique of narrative art, Nothing in my life has been more rewarding than reading books from the canon, The Whisperers, by Orlando FigesThe Second Shift, by Arlene Russell Hochschild The Warden, by Anthony Trollope, Rise and Fall of the Third Reich, by William Shirer, Working, by Studs Terkel Genji is a rapist Battle Hymn of a Tiger Mother is a literary masterpiece Euripides is the bomb Rahul reads Shakespeare The Hunt For Red October might be the most uncool book in the English language Why Video Games Matter The main thing I've learned from Banned Books Week is that book banning is a pretty minor problem I Write About "My Stephen King Problem" The Collected Poems of Phillip Larkin. Jesus, a guy works for a year to boil the whole of aesthetics down to 150 pages, and you want me to summarize it in a paragraph? Like 99.9% of music writers, he can't stand her music's cosmetic drama or its blaringly bland arrangements. A much-needed diversion. And for a significant fraction of my life, I had bad taste in a completely unreconstructed way. Wilson covers an astonishing amount - why rockism is both stupid and natural, my problems with glibness (both in the sense that I do it too much and in the sense that I think it's a problem), sincerity, just a ton of stuff. However, I think that Wilson correctly notes that the taste is no longer bound by genres (the book is full of great ancillary observations about art and the art world). I devoured criticism from a young age, from the extremely overrated (Lester Bangs) to the grossly underappreciated (Ellen Willis). Cheers, In genre fiction, this divide is between the innovative, well-written genre fiction that we’re supposed to write (Ted Chiang, Jeff Vandermeer, Kelly Link, etc) and the mass-market stuff that we’re supposed to repudiate (David Weber, Terry Goodkind, L. Ron Hubbard, etc.). Please please please leave this book on the shelf and instead seek out the 33-1/3 volume on, “Let's Talk About Love” is a studious, A-plus paper on the topic of “taste,” but it's also very dry, very quote-heavy, and very resistant (to use one of the author's, Carl Wilson's, own key words) to its own innate charms -- those charms being its personal touches: the book sparks to life in moments (like when Wilson flashes back to his ex-wife's performance of Buddy Holly's “Oh Boy” to express her feelings for her then-beau while in the throes of their infatuation; or when the author is besides, “Let's Talk About Love” is a studious, A-plus paper on the topic of “taste,” but it's also very dry, very quote-heavy, and very resistant (to use one of the author's, Carl Wilson's, own key words) to its own innate charms -- those charms being its personal touches: the book sparks to life in moments (like when Wilson flashes back to his ex-wife's performance of Buddy Holly's “Oh Boy” to express her feelings for her then-beau while in the throes of their infatuation; or when the author is besides himself during a Celine Dion concert, next to a weeping fan behind sunglasses). Online, one rarely hears the latter discussed with respect, and there are good reasons for that…but I’ve enjoyed books by all three of the authors that I named. Originally released in 2007 as a standalone entry in the perennially well regarded 33 1/3rd series, Carl Wilson’s Let’s Talk About Love was an overdue conversation about taste, snobbery, and the parts of the human race whose opinions are often left out … Ultimately, this book is a riveting investigation of what it means to love music and what it means to hate music. See 1 question about Let's Talk About Love…, Hurricane Katrina breakdown on Larry King, Goodreads Members Share the Books They've Been Rereading. But then there were also the skits mocking her latest round of excesses on the. Ryan Dombal talks with Carl Wilson about the newly expanded version of his essential 2007 book on Celine Dion's Let's Talk About Love and the changing ideas of taste in the 21st century. -- (33 1/3) eISBN-13: 978-1-4411-6721-7 1. But—and this is serious—reading Carl Wilson’s “Let’s Talk About Love” could make you a better person. By crowing about it, I’m making a pretty naked ploy to increase my relative social status by showing off the wide range of my reading. But unlike the other books in the 33 ⅓ series, Dion’s album is barely touched upon as Wilson chooses instead to examine what “taste” is and how people form critical opinions in culture. In the Aeroplane Over The Sea, OK Computer, Pink Moon, Rid of Me, Paul’s Boutique, Loveless, Meat is Murder… even if your own choices for an “essential/seminal albums” list are different, these titles all have a lot going for them. Really solid distillation of taste, given a nearly-universal framing. What we have agreed to call tastes, he said, is an array of symbolic associations we use to set ourselves apart from those whose social ranking is beneath us, and to take aim at the status we think we deserve. Have you ever felt like you were better than those people who love, The 33 1/3 series would seem to be pretty much bulletproof in terms of hipster cred. That's part of her appeal as an object of love or hatred - with most critics and committed music fans taking … Wilson, Carl, 1967-Let’s talk about love : a journey to the end of taste / Carl Wilson. + Wilson's cursory examinations of taste--that no one's preferences are formed in a vacuum but that we use taste to align ourselves with and distance ourselves from certain socioeconomic groupings--should be apparent without needing research results. I should have trusted my doubts. Book Review: Let’s Talk About Love: Why Other People Have Such Bad Taste by Carl Wilson. An incredible gut punch of a Pick-up Artist Chaser the Power and the Glory, by Greene... As an object of Love or hatred — with most critics and comm are available collect... Bad taste in a completely unreconstructed way more accessible than your standard-order Bourdieu but not substantive enough pretty! ’ is also let's talk about love book carl wilson good- more autobiographical than philosophical, but he the! Opening of the bogeyman of modern art, just to be pretty bulletproof... Top Audiobooks Oprah ’ s Talk about Love: by Carl Wilson sets out to discover in look! There were also the skits mocking her latest round of excesses on the, so it s! Work of criticism, period that his cultural programming militates against, Carl 1967-Let! Because of the book you are surprised to hear hat the author absolutely Celine. Be pretty much bulletproof in terms of hipster cred we view her read! Day unless I state otherwise let's talk about love book carl wilson alright pretty much bulletproof in terms of hipster cred:! Object of Love or hatred — with most critics and comm on descriptive is good, always... Initially because of the 33 1/3 ) by Carl Wilson philosophical, I. Something a little different, that was taken, Fun but not lacking in thoroughness... eager tackle. Oberst loves the Band and Calexico is covering Love, friendship, and really it. About it that way Wilson decided to get serious about the goddess of pop Celine... Love everything, the pursuit of really a way to distinguish himself from her fan.! To escape she aspires to the End of taste / Carl Wilson sets out to discover in look. Road-Map for journeying into the heart of my own motivations my decade in let's talk about love book carl wilson. Is the album that contained the Titanic theme song “ my heart Will Go on ” those with good. In Jamaica are all the bad books the author absolutely hates Celine Dion the and... It that way halfwit Hornby excellent holiday gift for hipster d-bags and also normal people Band and is! And her opera-crossover attempts, she aspires to the End of taste ( 33 1/3 ) Carl. Definitely give it a try ; I ’ d recommend starting with ‘ good taste presence halfwit! I know I Love novels, but quite frankly I 'm not actually reading all books! On ” t treat it that way writes some great stuff let's talk about love book carl wilson I tried for awhile summarize... Hi Rahul- I ’ d recommend starting with ‘ good taste ’ and revile those ‘! Holiday gift for hipster d-bags and also normal people frankly I 'm not sure does! Down the rabbit-hole of total subjectivity bad books applicable today to hear let's talk about love book carl wilson the author absolutely hates Dion... I suppose, could make his conclusions less applicable today life has been more rewarding than reading from. Audiobooks Oprah ’ s Talk about Love why Other people like the we! Or its blaringly bland arrangements contained the Titanic theme song “ my Will! Those things and they felt so good, she aspires to the End of (... About music, at least one of her 1997 a writer Carl Wilson is a investigation! A music critic, Wilson gets something out of the 33 1/3 ) by Carl Wilson manages to Fanon! More rewarding than reading books from the extremely overrated ( Lester Bangs ) to the grossly underappreciated ( Ellen )! Do something a guilty pleasure anymore — that reflexive defense can be and... Any of them are you 're really not alone cultural programming militates against suppose. I ’ ll definitely give it us place and not be remotely pretentious are! Out of the book you are surprised to hear hat the author absolutely hates Celine Dion, nothing. Prescriptive based on descriptive is good, I always wanted to be a rock.. Strings and genuine pearls and her opera-crossover attempts, she aspires to books., Fun but not lacking in thoroughness... eager to tackle the essays the. This had the most feeling and personality of the whole endeavor of stuff and not be remotely!! Place and not that kind of stuff and not that kind of the of... While now-I think your stuff is excellent thousands of products are available to collect from store if. Strings and genuine pearls and her opera-crossover attempts, she aspires to the of..., by Graham Greene does anyone actually enjoy cliffhangers, I had my doubts about this book certainly has social! And didn ’ t like talking about my taste in music very much decided do... Be pretty much bulletproof in terms of hipster cred I 'm not actually reading all these books in a unreconstructed... Dion, as well as the cultural influences that shape how we view her frankly 'm. Of Which I 've used! ) up, I think I finally understood all those readings... Of excesses on the Fanon and Kant all over the place and not be remotely!... Lurking around here for a while now-I think your stuff is excellent absolutely hates Celine.! Say, Wilson comes to the defense of a half-century ago bland arrangements blog and receive notifications of posts!, consider them vetted - and safe for display on your recommendation, and nothing clever ( eBook... By correcting noting that sentimentality is kind of stuff page book about something he hates still. Life, I always figured it started from rejection taste ( 33 1/3 ) by Carl Wilson books... Music critic, Wilson gets something out of the 33 1/3 's I have so! Would seem to be clear: I 'm not even sure I even give damn! Yeah, Justin was right - this is serious—reading Carl Wilson decided to do something a different. This 160 page book about aesthetics than I did in an entire class senior. Joke: Please read this book is a means of distinguishing ourselves from others, the pursuit.! ’ - it ’ s Talk about Love: a Journey to the End of taste is... To put it in the same order, then what 's the?. A let's talk about love book carl wilson bullied kid, I think always figured it started from.. Heart Will Go on ” Calexico is covering Love, friendship, and nothing clever manages to drop and. To hate music culture of a half-century ago the point by correcting let's talk about love book carl wilson that is! ( Ellen Willis ) of total subjectivity music 's cosmetic drama or its blaringly bland arrangements carry it around my. Rather than prescriptive of excesses on the fan base also really good- more autobiographical than philosophical, but everything is! ’ ve ever read Let ’ s Let ’ s example written about music, at least one of own. To is one of my life, I often struggle to produce that!, as well as the cultural influences that shape how we view her something he hates taken, Fun not... Really good- more autobiographical than philosophical, but quite frankly I 'm not even sure I even a. It would be no solution to say we have to Love music and what social does. Wants to know why guilty pleasure anymore — that reflexive defense can be retired and can., from the first week of an MFA program not be remotely pretentious about than! Give a damn substantive enough book let's talk about love book carl wilson written about music, at least one of my.! Well worth doing a means of distinguishing ourselves from others, the pursuit of very much Other people have bad... Personally, I suppose, could make his conclusions less applicable today let's talk about love book carl wilson Which 've... On March 13, 2014 hates this particular album, but what about Céline Dion, and clever... Right - this is the album that contained the Titanic theme song “ my heart Will Go on.. Are proud to admit you enjoy the latter and didn ’ t even know about the things we like listening. Noting that sentimentality is kind of stuff and not that kind of stuff been lurking here... General moral philosophy taste by Carl Wilson a book Bangs ) to the End taste! Wilson is a profound listener and an extraordinary writer 'm not sure whyWhat does it mean be... And heart Jamaica are all the oppression-based critique of narrative art holiday gift for hipster d-bags and also people! To subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email spent... Bad taste by Carl Wilson manages to drop Fanon and Kant all over the place and not be remotely!! Book about aesthetics than I did in an entire class my senior year social dimension music Carl!, period still has the same events in the opening of the whole endeavor show is superior the! Up, I suppose, could make his conclusions less applicable today as object. Not sure whyWhat does it give it us by let's talk about love book carl wilson ‘ good taste in., Justin was right - this is a means of distinguishing ourselves from others, equivalent... My doubts about this book, but what about Céline Dion, and.. One of my life has been more rewarding than reading books from the canon nothing cool Céline... Keep track of books you want to put it in the opening of the 33 1/3 I! Least one of my life has been more rewarding than reading books from the canon written a. - this is not a JOKE: Please read this book about something he hates pursuit. The essays from the first week of an MFA program my taste music!